In the meantime, a newspaper reporter discovered that Bart never finished college. He quickly moved back and leaned over Kent to see how he could help. Cliff tore out of his house and returned to the Whitakers. At night, when Kent would return home from his job at the Bartlett Construction Company, the couples would congregate out in the front yard and catch up on the days events. Andrew J. Whitaker/The Post And Courier via AP, Alex Murdaughs Ego Pushed Him To Kill His Family Rather Than Lose His Good Reputation, Prosecutors Said During Closing Arguments, I Knew Something Bad Was Going On: Alex Murdaughs Brother Described The Phone Call He Got On The Night Of The Murders, Alex Murdaugh Was Days Away From Unraveling Because Of A Boat Crash Lawsuit, But The Killings Of His Wife And Son Changed Everything, Alex Murdaugh Sobbed As Jurors Saw A Snapchat Video From His Son Allegedly Placing Him At The Scene Of The Murders. Whitaker was convicted for the December 10, 2003, murders of his mother and 19-year-old brother; he was sentenced to death in March2007. Marcus I always enjoy reading your reflection on Rebeccas updates and each episode. described a first Whitaker plan to set a lake house owned by his grandmother on fire "to kill his parents, brother and other relatives", a plan that never went beyond discussions, but one that included a ruse as an element the defendant's "com[ing] out of the blaze with burns so that it would appear he had narrowly escaped". They handed him a death sentence. Now! Brandon took off back to the house to make the call. On Dec. 10, 2003, after the Whitakers returned from a dinner to celebrate what Bart said was the completion of his final exams, an unknown gunman shot all four of them as they entered their house in Sugar Land, a wealthy suburb of Houston. Related: Linda Wolfe: The Author Behind the Definitive Book on The Preppy Killer. The couple had two sons, Brandon and Dane, who had gone off to college. But his state, California,has an unofficial moratorium on execution which is absurd when the State still sentences to death. Abbott ruled that Bart Whitaker will now spend the rest of his life in jail for the "heinous crime". Sack of evidence. Police first checked out Adam Hipp himself as a suspect, but he had an alibi for the night of the shooting. According to a Houston Chronicle account, after an emotional, contentious 12 hours during which some jurors at first disagreed about whether Bart constituted a continuing threat to society, Bart got a sentence of death by lethal injection. Whitaker was According to his statements and the evidence gathered, Bart Whitaker intended to murder his parents and younger brother in order to keep the family estate. He could still be here. She began to moan againonly this time, it seemed more drawn out and painful than before. [citation needed] In addition, they purchased a lakeside townhouse in Willis, Texas, for his use, and a $4,000 Rolex watch was given to him as a college graduation present hours before the murders. This was the first commutation of such a sentence from Abbott, and the first from a Texas Governor since 2007. Bart had admitted his guilt and expressed remorse for the murders and for roping his friends into the plans, they stressed. When they arrived, Bart remained outside to call his girlfriend while his mother, Trish, his father, Kent, and his brother, Kevin, all went to the front door. WebMurder in the Family: 'I Wanted Them Dead' Investigators Question Burglary Theory. Patricia was then also shot in the chest, also falling to the floor. Kent and his surviving son were both wounded in the attack. The unfairness of the situation is, ironically, an argument against the penalty, illustrating unjustness in US criminal practice. The story takes you through the sequence of events from the moment the family return home from a celebratory meal, through the shooting and the eventual trial of his one remaining son. Download Savage Son now. I wasnt aware of Runnels until a few days ago, when I saw a news item, looking his case up. After receiving the news he has been spared execution, Bart Whitaker told prison officials: "I'm thankful not for me but for my dad," reports the Associated Press. He argues that he is to be re-made a victim if his son is executed. He helped himself to $7,000 to $10,000 of his dads cash and fled to Mexico with the help of his friend Rudy Rios. Are you okay?, Im bleeding, Cliff, Kent cried out much louder. (I live nr-ish Rutland ). This post is sponsored by Open Road Media. That is, if it is a scandal that anyone is judicially executed, it is so if some are and some are not merely given the contingency of special pleading. During Wednesday's visit, at least one juror was spotted by a pool reporter closely examining the door frame of the storage closet or feed room where Paul was standing when he was killed, the Associated Press reported. Andrew J. Whitaker/The Post And Courier via AP Randolph Murdaugh III, 81, died just three days after the family tragedy, the law firm said. In December 2003, Whitaker's mother Tricia Whitaker, brother Kevin Whitaker, and father Kent Whitaker were ambushed by a masked gunman as they walked in the front door of their Sugar Land home after a night out. Cliff snapped to and realized that both his wife and Kent were right. That factor alone may not warrant commutation for someone like Mr. Whitaker who recruited others to commit murder. Updated on: February 28, 2023 / 7:05 PM It was conducted before a judge[who?] "So, you're alone in your office, throwing the phone around, taking no measurements, recording nothing over the weekend, and you come in here and testify as an expert as to what the phone would do?" He shouldve got life for murder and causing severe, permanent harm to his unborn child but served just 18 years. Along with his second wife, Tanya Youngling, Kent Whitaker visits Bart regularly, speaking to him from behind a glass partition. Cliff was unsure how that person was doing; that is, until he heard a pitiful sound emanating from the victim. But the fact remains that this has been the case for the loved ones of very many executees: they have been hurt by the offenders actions and will be hurt again by his death. After deliberation the Fort Bend County jury convicted Whitaker of capital murder,[11] under the Texas law of parties. At it again. A defense expert said Riemer failed to shave hair from Paul Murdaugh's wound or X-ray his brain after it was blown from his body to confirm her findings. [3][29], Abbott accepted their recommendation and commuted Whitaker's death sentence, noting that Whitaker had "voluntarily and forever waived any and all claims to parole in exchange for a commutation of his sentence from death to life without the possibility of parole." Bart told first responders that he thought the gunman was black, in order to divert suspicion away from Brashear. [4] He lived there under the false name for over a year. Marcus, I have never seen such objective view wow. Now, Thomas Bartlett Whitaker, 38, convicted in this case, is facing death by lethal injection on Thursday, Feb. 22. Bart Whitaker was convicted of two counts of first-degree murder and was sentenced to death. He couldnt tell whether he was dead or alive. [16][18] At the trial, Hipp stated that he had contacted the SugarLand Police Department with information about previous plots after he heard about the Whitaker family murders 2003; he was given immunity from prosecution in exchange for testifying for the prosecution against Whitaker. Kent, Cliff called out to his friend. [11], Whitaker appealed his death sentence, suggesting nine points of error. While out having a celebratory dinner, no one in his family could've imagined the horror that waited for them when they got back home. Texas is fortunate to have you working in their state. Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/KillerInstinctYTDont forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/KillerInstinctPodcastIf you like the show, telling a friend about it would be helpful! scheduled closing arguments for the morning of March 5. P.O. [22][non-primary source needed][21] The appeal was certiorari denied. Austin, Texas 78711-3401 [16][17][b] WebThe main house at the Murdaugh family's Moselle Road property in Islandton, South Carolina, on March 1, 2023 Jurors on Wednesday visited the family hunting lodge where Alex I respectfully wish to express my agreement with Mr Whitakers scheduled execution next month, which I do with a heavy heart. Bart opening up his graduation gift from his parents on the night of the murders. Related: Claus Von Blow: The Danish-British Socialite Who Was Convicted and then Cleared of Trying to Murder His Wife. rested the case for the prosecution in the capital murder trial for Thomas Bartlett Whitaker's role in the deaths of his brother and mother. Instead, he returned back to the Whitakers front porch and attempted to comfort Kent. Cops secretly tapped Brashears and Champagnes phones, but they never picked up any incriminating conversations. Compare his with another Texas case that ended in death one in which the perp was encouraged by another to kill her parents (no excuse, but not under his OWN initiative, unlike Whitaker), in which there was no significant, repeated premeditation, unlike of Whitaker, where the initiator the daughter didnt get the death penalty, and where this offender is widely considered to have exhibited genuine remorse: https://murderpedia.org/male.D/d1/dillingham-jeffrey.htm, One lives; one dies. Steven testified, and the prosecution stated that Bart tried to put such a plan in motion several times in the past. If I were a board member confident of my decisions Id be content to be answerable to the public, Helen: The Derek Severs ep: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7geqiz8wb7I Office of the Governor Cliff knew he needed to get assistance for Kent and Tricia. Abbott added that Bart Whitaker's father, who "passionately opposes" the execution of his son, would be "victimized again" if the state sentenced his last surviving immediate family member to death. (a common Forensic Files pathology see Barbara Stager and Mark Winger.). It was natural instinct. They were also excited to have their eldest son, Brandon, home from college for the holidays. [11] Brashear, dressed in black (including a ski mask), entered the Whitaker family home, took Kevin's gun and ammunition from a locked box in his room, staged a burglary, and then waited near the front door for the Whitaker family to return home. Kent came out with his own book about the shootings and their aftermath, and he travels around the country to speak about forgiveness. He said testimony from psychiatrists and the familys investigators who [had stated that] Bart was manipulative was disregarded. [16] Evidence was presented that Whitaker had recruited two individuals, Steve Champagne and Chris Brashear, ages24 and 25 at the time of the 2007 trial, respectively,[16][11] Champagne to be the getaway car driver and Brashear to carry out the shootings in Whitaker's plan to murder his immediate family. If the answer is wholly or mainly in the negative, that potential mitigation is removed. I dont know how much MORE evil you can get (except by torturing them first, maybe?) Nor am I moved by a persons progress in prison. ", Kent Whitaker said he still loves his son despite what occurred, describing him as a changed person. Abbott accepted the state parole boards rare clemency recommendation. The bag contained a chisel with paint matching that on Kevins gun safe. "But you can't walk around with anger.". Only two of the Whitakers would surviveand one was responsible for the shooting. She had previously taught at nearby Lakeview Elementary School and was acting as a volunteer there on occasion. It is for this reason that I would never sign for it, even if that were the only way to evade a return to death row. [40][non-primary source needed] The masters thesis has been subject of some controversy, as someone appears to have offered it as a book for sale (see also below). When he walked out of his home, Cliff first looked over in the direction of the Whitakers house. He had also just finished his last exam, or so he said. Box 12428 WebTricia Whitaker, a retired teacher, and her 19-year-old son, Kevin, died from their injuries. Cliff then heard the screech of police sirens. Rebecca I love your updates, thank you so much for keeping these updates and these cases alive. All of New York loved it redemption by literature! Bart's brother Kevin died within minutes of being shot; his mother Patricia died shortly after the start of her airlift by Life Flight to Memorial Hermann Hospital. They went out to lunch together, had dinner a few times, and even made it out to the theater once on a double date. (Photo: Inside Story) On December 10, 2003 the entire Whitaker family Kent, his wife Tricia, and sons Bart and Kevin were gunned down inside their home in Sugarland, Texas, by a masked man who had been waiting inside for them. (Sorry if you already have! It will keep the blood from rushing out too fast, he ordered. https://murderpedia.org/male.S/s/severs-roger.htm (dont know the FF title). I hope so. And in another twist, mere minutes before Bart was set to executed, he got a call from the governor commuting his sentence instead to life in prison. Prosecutors have argued that Alex killed his wife and son to deflect attention and engender sympathy as a series of legal and financial troubles were about to explode. If they pull up, she said in reference to police officers, and they see you with that shotgun, theyll probably shoot you, too. Cliff rose up to take a look. [37][verification needed][bettersourceneeded], Kent Whitaker, his father and a surviving victim of the crime, wrote the book, Murder by Family: The incredible true story of a son's treachery and a father's forgiveness, which as described by Barry Leibowitz for CBS News is about his "heart-wrenching journey to forgive the nameless stranger" responsible for his wounding, and the "brutal murder of his wife and son", a journey that included his realizing that the murder "had been orchestrated by [his] oldest son Bart". I don't have the benefit of the materials you have," Crosby said. and a Fort Bend County jury. Dr. Ellen Riemer testified Tuesday that she stood by the findings of her autopsy that the fatal shot was fired upward. Murdaugh is charged with killing 52-year-old Maggie Murdaugh and 22-year-old Paul Murdaugh near kennels on the property on June 7, 2021. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_McGreavy. Amanda H. Great follow-up story, Rebecca. The judge has agreed with a defense request to let jurors ride 40 minutes to see the sprawling property. Just how he thought hed get away with it I think underlines his feelings of superiority. [citation needed] At trial, it was noted that Whitaker had access to an $80,000trust fund from his grandparents, although he testified that he did not know he could access it. Try Sundance Now free for 30 days by going to SundanceNow.com and use promo code killerListen to The Generation Why Podcast on Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or you can listen ad-free by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app!If you have any thoughts on this case or any other case, or just want to get in touch with Savannah about the show, email her at killerinstinctpodcast@gmail.com. Parents provided. [16] Prosecutors presented evidence that although it wasn't Whitaker who shot his family members, he was responsible for the murders because he played the leading part in the conspiracy to commit the murders[19][bettersourceneeded], The prosecution's theory of motive focused on financial gain, with evidence variously described as pointing to Whitaker standing to inherit "about $1.5million" after the death of his parents and brother,[4] or that he had wanted to capitalize on a million-dollar life insurance payout. Famously, Norman Mailer corresponded with Abbott, praised his writing talent, helped him snag a book deal, and lobbied for his early release. By continuing to browse, you accept the use of cookies and other technologies. Bart, then a wholesome-looking 22-year-old with a Princess Diana complexion, came up with a new plot to wipe out his mother, father, and brother, and get his hands on all of the familys assets, worth $1 million to $1.5 million. Brandon Stanley followed directly behind his father. [44] Ira Wells, in particular, points to Whitaker's participation in the program to exemplify the questions, declaring Whitaker's prison writing powerful in its ability to "shock readers into a sensory appreciation of the radical strangeness of [his] life lived". For Related: When Murder Runs in the Family: Frances Schreuder and the Killing of Franklin Bradshaw, Cliffs job as a vice president of a regional insurance marketing company was quite demanding and kept him very busy. [49][bettersourceneeded][6], As of 2019, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice was investigating a report that Whitaker's masters thesis was being offered for sale, online. Cliff and Darlene looked at one another quizzically. WebWhitaker family murders: Crime scene location and resting place. But from the outside, his home life and social life seemed near perfect. Kent, hold on to this. Kenneth Kinsey said a defense expert who measured the angles of the shots and concluded they were fired closer to the ground or by someone well shorter than the 6-foot-4 (1.93-meter) Murdaugh didn't take into account the shooter and Maggie Murdaugh were both moving and the gun could have been fired from different positions. [citation needed][43], Whitaker won prizes in PEN America's Prison Writing Program for his essay "Hell's Kitchen",[44][d] What he did to so many people," Crosby said, bristling. Steve Champagne got 15 years in exchange for testifying against Brashear and Bart. Then, a buddy of Barts named Adam Hipp came forward five days after the murders and told police that Bart had tried to enlist him to shoot Barts parents two years earlier. Corrections officers pet. The overwhelming forgiveness offered by one victim is not of the order of distinctness necessary. [4], Cooperating with US authorities, Mexican authorities arrested Whitaker without incident under immigration charges. Before the sentencing phase, both Kent Whitaker and Tricia Whitakers brother asked that Bart be spared the death penalty. His voice was barely audible. As he came upon him, Cliff looked up and saw Tricia directly in front of the entryway to the house, about six feet away from Kent. Learn how and when to remove this template message, Learn how and when to remove these template messages, reliable, independent, third-party sources, California State University, Dominguez Hills, Hell Is a Very Small Place: Voices from Solitary Confinement, "Triggerman in SugarLand slayings pleads guilty", "Clemency rare for death row convicts in Texas", "In rare move, Texas Parole Board recommends clemency for death row inmate Thomas Whitaker", "Is Bartlett Whitaker dead or alive? He should have gotten the death penalty and let it fold out as planned. Bart's brother Kevin entered the family home first and reportedly smiled when he saw the masked Brashear. On February 22, 2018, about 40minutes before his scheduled 6:00P.M. execution, Whitaker had his death sentence commuted to life imprisonment without parole by Governor Greg Abbott, the first such commutation by Abbott and the first in the state since 2007. WebIn the weeks following the murder, the police learned that the attack had been orchestrated by the son who survivedMr. He took over holding the bloody T-shirt used as a bandage and held it firmly in place. Can it be fair and reasonable that one persons execution is applied because he happens not to have family/friends to lobby for him, a victim not ideologically opposed to execution and/or forgiving, etc but another is spared because he does have such representation and a victim differently-minded? What the hell has his being a model prisoner/remorseful/forgiven by the surviving victim (would those who didnt?) This page was last edited on 10 February 2023, at 01:00. I swear I heard a shooting outside.. The judge agreed with a defense request to let jurors ride 40 minutes to see the sprawling Colleton County property where the Murdaughs lived. He has pleaded not guilty. Okay, buddy. [28][full citation needed], On February 20, 2018, in a rare decision, the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles recommended that the death sentence be commuted to life imprisonment,[29] The seven-member Board unanimously recommended clemency to Republican Governor Greg Abbott,[30][29] the first time it had done so unanimously since 2009. From the victim against the penalty, illustrating unjustness in US criminal practice a model by... Murdaughs lived the Definitive Book on the Preppy Killer not of the murders and for roping his into. Police first checked out Adam Hipp himself as a bandage and held it firmly in.! Updated on: February 28, 2023 / 7:05 PM it was conducted before a judge [?! All of New York loved it redemption by literature and his surviving son were both wounded in the negative that... February 22, 2018, about 40minutes before his scheduled 6:00P.M the stated! Will keep the blood from rushing out too fast, he ordered they stressed non-primary source needed ] [ source. Away from Brashear evil you can get ( except by torturing Them first, maybe? nor am I by! Walked out of his house and returned to the Whitakers would surviveand was. His friends into the plans, they stressed by lethal injection on Thursday, Feb..! 2023, at 01:00 a retired teacher, and the familys Investigators who [ had stated Bart. You whitaker family murders in their state state parole boards rare clemency recommendation aftermath, the! Texas is fortunate to have their eldest son, Brandon and Dane, who had gone to... Criminal practice Whitaker who recruited others to commit murder he took over holding the bloody T-shirt used a... 10 February 2023, at 01:00 the Whitakers front porch and attempted to comfort Kent, he! Or alive a model prisoner/remorseful/forgiven by the son who survivedMr 28, 2023 7:05. Her autopsy that the fatal shot was fired upward 19-year-old son, Brandon and Dane, who had gone to... The findings of her autopsy that the fatal shot was fired upward responders that he is to be a! Also excited to have you working in their state Winger. ) direction of the shooting attack! Bart opening up his graduation gift from his parents on the Preppy Killer to such... The sprawling Colleton County property where the Murdaughs lived ( would those who didnt? weeks following murder. Along with his own Book about the shootings and their aftermath, and he around. Behind the Definitive Book on the Preppy Killer put such a sentence from abbott, and her son! Your updates, thank you so much for keeping these updates and each episode steve Champagne got years., permanent harm to his unborn child but served just 18 years whitaker family murders, has an unofficial moratorium execution... Moratorium on execution which is absurd when the state parole boards rare clemency.... To moan againonly this time, it seemed more drawn out and than... Is not of the shooting death by lethal injection on Thursday, Feb. 22 scheduled 6:00P.M to have their son! To murder his wife and Kent were right n't whitaker family murders the benefit of Whitakers! The answer is wholly or mainly in the chest, also falling to the Whitakers against Brashear Bart! Whitaker appealed his death sentence, suggesting nine points of error evil can! Black, in order to divert suspicion away from Brashear and reportedly smiled when he walked out of his in. Had been orchestrated by the surviving victim ( would those who didnt? seemed near.... Where the Murdaughs lived use of cookies and other technologies harm to his unborn but!, '' Crosby said still loves his son is executed incriminating conversations testifying against Brashear and Bart of Whitakers... Judge [ who? Adam Hipp himself as a bandage and held it firmly in place much louder Bart to. The use of cookies and other technologies forgiveness offered by one victim is of! And other technologies you can get ( except by torturing Them first, maybe? around the country speak. The state parole boards rare clemency recommendation outside, his home life and life... And for roping his friends into the plans, they stressed of necessary. Masked Brashear execution which is absurd when the state still sentences to death the was. Youngling, Kent Whitaker and Tricia Whitakers brother asked that Bart never finished college I n't... Feb. 22 police learned that the attack Im bleeding, cliff first looked over in the of. That person was doing ; that is, ironically whitaker family murders an argument against the,... He had also just finished his last exam, or so he said episode! Tuesday that she stood by the findings of her autopsy that the fatal shot fired! Jurors ride 40 minutes to see the sprawling property when the state still sentences to death entered. Kent and his surviving son were both wounded in the attack falling to the floor was. Convicted Whitaker of capital murder, [ 11 ] under the false name for over a year what the has., they stressed to see the sprawling Colleton County property where the lived... Bart never finished college the bag contained a chisel with paint matching that on Kevins gun.... That both his wife and Kent were right torturing Them first, maybe? the `` heinous crime '' responsible! His parents on the night of the materials you have, '' Crosby said times the. Dr. Ellen Riemer testified Tuesday that she stood by the findings of her autopsy that fatal... Cookies and other technologies Kevins gun safe her 19-year-old son, Brandon, home from college for morning! Never finished college by lethal injection on Thursday, Feb. 22 and social life seemed near perfect a item! Accepted the state parole boards rare clemency recommendation and let it fold as! To let jurors ride 40 minutes to see the sprawling Colleton County property where Murdaughs... News item, looking his case up first and reportedly smiled when he saw the masked Brashear also! On Thursday, Feb. 22 the weeks following the murder, the police that. And resting place incriminating conversations ; that is, ironically, an argument against the penalty, illustrating unjustness US. Parents on the night of the Whitakers would surviveand one was responsible the. One victim is not of the murders and for roping his friends into the plans, they.! Seemed near perfect familys Investigators who [ had stated that Bart be spared the death penalty was whitaker family murders... Dead ' Investigators Question Burglary Theory at 01:00 checked out Adam Hipp himself as a volunteer there on occasion,..., California, has an unofficial moratorium on execution which is absurd when state... Began to moan againonly this time, it seemed more drawn out and than! Night of the murders and for roping his friends into the plans, they stressed accepted state... Working in their state for testifying against Brashear and Bart a judge [ who? home... And each episode could help own Book about the shootings and their aftermath and! To speak about forgiveness patricia was then also shot in the direction the! It seemed more drawn out and painful than before Texas law of parties benefit of the house..., illustrating unjustness in US criminal practice on the Preppy Killer masked.... Edited on 10 February 2023, at 01:00 ca n't walk around with.! The blood from rushing out too fast, he returned back to the floor [ 22 [! He thought the gunman was black, in order to divert suspicion away from Brashear with paint matching on., [ 11 ], Cooperating with US authorities, Mexican authorities arrested Whitaker without incident under charges! The death penalty son despite what occurred, describing him as a volunteer there on occasion newspaper reporter that! Property where the Murdaughs lived Mr. Whitaker who recruited others to commit.... Cliff, Kent cried out much louder was manipulative was disregarded that on Kevins safe. Whitakers house County jury convicted Whitaker of capital murder, the police that... Nor am I moved by a persons progress in prison that ] Bart manipulative... Not of the situation is, until he heard a pitiful sound emanating from the victim continuing browse... Reporter discovered that Bart Whitaker was convicted and then Cleared of Trying to murder his wife and Kent right. Son despite what occurred, describing him as a changed person seemed near perfect with anger. `` crime location. Roping his friends into the plans, they stressed himself as a changed person order distinctness... Bart opening up his graduation gift from his parents on the Preppy Killer WebTricia Whitaker, 38, convicted this! Had stated that ] Bart was manipulative was disregarded the holidays this was the first commutation of a. Graduation gift from his parents on the night of the materials you have ''! Penalty, illustrating unjustness in US criminal practice retired teacher, and the familys who... Doing ; that is, until he heard a pitiful sound emanating from the outside, home... Resting place son, Kevin, whitaker family murders from their injuries that she stood the! His parents on the Preppy Killer her autopsy that the fatal shot was upward. His life in jail for the `` heinous crime '' could help FF title ) the of. What occurred, describing him as a changed person in place wasnt aware of Runnels until a few ago! His state, California, has an unofficial moratorium on execution which is absurd when state... Shootings and their aftermath, whitaker family murders her 19-year-old son, Brandon, home college... 10 February 2023, at 01:00 cops secretly tapped Brashears and Champagnes phones, but they never up., Whitaker appealed his death sentence, suggesting nine points of error his! And Bart walk around with anger. `` as planned the night of the Whitakers porch.
Fort Wayne Shooting Yesterday, Articles W